Oct, 27
Summary of player feedback and my comments

Some of the dust has settled after the last patch was released, so it’s time for a summary. Thanks to a promotion and Steam’s autumn sale, there has been an influx of new players. I would like to welcome everyone on board, and encourage you to participate in discussions and take part in the development of the game. I’m always open to ideas and your input is very important to me.

Alpha23 was probably the biggest gameplay update released so far, and as much as I had high hopes that it will be a big improvement of KeeperRL, it received a bit of negative feedback.

Processing negative comments is pretty hard. First of all there is a danger that they are not representative of overall player opinion – of about 2000 people that tried out Alpha23, only about 1-2% posted their comments. I take feedback very seriously, but my decisions will be different depending on whether it’s only that 1% that are unhappy, or if there are another 1000 players who didn’t like the update, but didn’t comment.

There can also be clashes of my personal vision of the game, and people’s expectations and playing styles. I’ve recently learnt that some players have been building dungeons with over a hundred minions. I never planned gameplay around such big bases, so it’s understandable that some of the changes can conflict with such playing style. I need to take that into account when deciding if a particular piece of feedback is related to a bad design in the core of the game. Of course I try to cater to as many types of players as possible, but I also need to make some compromises to stick to my vision.

To get to specific feedback, it was mostly related to people not liking the new mana progression, having to use the full-control mode all the time or just generally finding the game too hard. I think the last two are very connected, as full-control gives a huge advantage to the player, so it forced me to increase enemy stats. Now staying in the real-time mode or even controlling just the team leader is not an option in most battles. I can definitely see how it breaks the game for some people.

It may sound dumb, but for me a big thing is that I personally enjoy playing KeeperRL with the new changes. The new tactical gameplay introduced by the full-control mode is very fun for me, and the mana progression gives me more challenge. While the new features will stay for now, I’ll try to improve them and remove as many rough edges as possible to give everyone a better playing experience. I’ll improve the interface and general handling of the full-control mode, and work on creature AI so that its tactical disadvantage is smaller. I will also try to improve the progression, although I think that tying it with conquest was a good decision.

Besides fixes, I already have some plans for the next update. As with Alpha23, it will continue the trend of adding new gameplay features and content, although I’m quite certain that this time they will be much less revolutionary. Once the plan is laid out, I will write a blog post about it.

COMMENTS

Home Forums Summary of player feedback and my comments

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7094

    thesnaman
    Participant

    The mana progression really took me by surprise and while I understand the goal I feel like it has moved too far. As it stands it will drive conquest, but I feel like you can still achieve that goal, without entirely removing alternate sources.

    There have been a lot of suggestions and a lot of response, because it cuts down on your freedom of action. Anyway, I was thinking of a couple things. You could have a altar, or statue, or magic circle, where the you might be able to put Shamans or other minions to allow for a slow trickle of Mana. Good for early game when you would like to progress some research. The idea of gaining mana by torturing and killing prisoner (dark though that maybe, haha) is a really good idea too. Sacrificing gold, sacrificing items, sacrificing minions, burning dead bodies could all easily give differing levels of mana based on the difficulty of action. Make like an old school Diablo II effigy out of body parts.

    The change right now is good in the way that drives action. It leads to a more dynamic play style. I think the same goal can be achieved if the rate of return on attacking enemies is much higher than the slow trickle you would get from having a shaman pray. On top of everything though, sacrificing prisoners on a dark altar is a pretty flippin sweet idea.

    Best of luck with everything, love the game, whatever gripes I have are lost in jubilance that I finally get to play a dungeon keeper game that has very little BS.

    cheers

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

 LATEST NEWS

Aug, 23

KeeperRL Alpha 25 hotfix 1 released

This is a bug fixing patch that takes care of a few issues in the Alpha 25 update. Many of them have been reported by players through the in-game "report bug" tool. Thanks to... more

Jul, 31

KeeperRL Alpha 25 is released!

KeeperRL Alpha 25 is finally out! This is another patch with a lot of gameplay improvements, focusing especially on dungeon development. It includes moat building, special items... more

Jul, 05

Alpha25 release plan

I haven't posted updates for a while, but KeeperRL's development has been quite steady. Among other things, I've done a lot of work in the UI department, of which you'll find a... more

May, 17

Gameplay features coming in Alpha25

I've been working on the next KeeperRL update at full steam for the past few weeks. The changes have all been oriented around gameplay and not very hard in terms of programming,... more

May, 09

Alpha24 hotfix

The direct download version of KeeperRL has been updated with a few bug fixes. I've also starting working on Alpha25 already, and will post an update on that in the next few... more

 

 PLAYERS SAID

There are no other games out there like KeeperRL. The game is a unique mixture of management, levelling, crafting, constructing, exploring, adventure etc. […] The possibility of interacting with other’s players monumental dungeons turn KeeperRL into one of the most promising games I’ve found.

dbvel

This game is amazing! It’s challenging, fun, unique, and exactly what you might expect it to be. For an early access game it’s incredible. And the thought that there’s more to come thrills me! I can’t wait to see how this awesome game will develop even more.

Avarti

Any time I touch another race, I get bent over like a cheap, overworked sex worker. I love sucking at this game so much.

DaavPuke