Jul, 03
Upcoming gameplay changes, part I

I recently stumbled upon an old Reddit “AMA” by Tynan Sylvester, the author of Rimworld. I hope he doesn’t mind if I quote chunk of one of his answers here. “What designers need to do is figure out the core of their game very early and just make that. Don’t get caught up in polish, or art, or start thinking that adding ancillary features will make the game sing. If that core doesn’t hit really hard and really grab players, the game is pretty much doomed. But if that core really works, everything added on will add huge value.”

I think it’s a very important point, and I’ve always felt that there is some wasted potential in the core gameplay of KeeperRL. I’m always trying to find ways to improve it, and the most recent effect was the immigration overhaul. The Alpha23 update will contain more major changes in KeeperRL’s gameplay in two major departments: progression and combat mechanics. I’ll split this post into two parts, and start with progression, leaving combat for part II.

Most games don’t make all of their content available right from the start, but instead uncover it piece by piece, such that when playing the game, you feel that you’re on a path that’s leading somewhere. I think we can define progression as a mechanic that prevents the player from reaching all of the game’s content at once. It’s pretty obvious that it’s a hugely important feature, and it can make or break a game.

I came up with the following methods of creating progression in base-building games.

  1. Making the building and management part of the game absorbing and challenging. This usually requires complex systems that create challenges for the player. Examples of games with such mechanics are: Dwarf Fortress, Rimworld, Gnomoria, Factorio.
  2. Having the player wait for stuff to complete. This includes slow resource extraction, tech research that takes time, etc. Even though this method is often used in successful games, I think it can give bad results if not used carefully.
  3. External challenges, like invaders, disasters, etc. They can strictly define progress, like in the tower defense genre, or be a side feature and just hinder the player’s efforts from time to time.
  4. Exploration and conquest outside of the player’s base. Only some base-building games have them. Conquest can be a requirement for winning the game, but it can also be tied more closely with progression by letting the player bring back loot and resources that are then used to improve his or her base.

I’ve decided long time ago that KeeperRL won’t be about complex management and building a’la Dwarf Fortress, because I don’t enjoy this kind of games that much, and I feel that I couldn’t design one well. This leaves the other three bullet points to think about.

A major issue in KeeperRL’s progression is that you can create a perfect army without being bothered much, and only then destroy all the villains. The end can also be boring, because you can be as strong as you want to. I realized that this is because the game rewards you for waiting with regeneration of mana. Waiting is only good when it comes with trade-offs, such as a risk of being invaded. But invasions are hard to balance in KeeperRL, and when the enemies are too aggressive, then the game becomes too hard for lot of players.

That’s why I tried a different direction and removed the waiting, such that mana is only awarded for conquering villains, and not generated in the library. It turns out that this simple change made the game much more interesting. Conquest is the only way to research technology, so it’s very strictly tied with your dungeon’s progression. It could potentially make the game too linear, but I think this can be mitigated by tweaking technologies and their cost, so that multiple research paths are optimal.

The biggest consequence of this change is that it creates a huge incentive for attacking. You are always desperate for more mana, so you’ll attack with weaker forces than before, which will create new challenges and interesting scenarios. There are more changes that need to come along, for example some structures and minions used to cost mana, but since it’s a more valuable resource now, the costs need to be tweaked. The primary use of the library room was to generate mana, but now it will only be a training room for spellcasting minions.

I know that there are players who are in more for base-building than the roguelike aspects of KeeperRL. This is where the endless mode will help, substituting conquest with defending your dungeon – mana will be rewarded for each deflected enemy wave.

As I’ve already mentioned, the next blog post will talk about changes in combat mechanics. I hope to be able to publish a testing build once all of the described changes are implemented in a basic form, and gather feedback from you. This will let me tweak and balance things or even revert the changes if they don’t work out. At the same time I will be implementing the other features planned in Alpha23: the endless mode and content additions.


Home Forums Upcoming gameplay changes, part I

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
  • #6769


    This was the best blog post I’ve read so far. It clearly lays out your vision and I agree with everything that’s written in it. Even though Keeper mode is the main mode, I’ve found adventurer mode to be more fun because it forces you to carefully choose your targets to level up, and I think that acquiring mana only through combat will impart the same sort of thought processes for Keeper mode.

    A couple of thoughts about this mana mechanic:

    1. While you posit that limiting research through successful conquest might make the game too linear, I think this can be mitigated if there is always a choice of which enemy to attack.

    2. The total amount of mana available will have to be carefully regulated. There should probably be some prevention mechanism in place so that players can’t farm individual tribe members for mana. Either mana should only be generated by killing the entire tribe, or the rate of recruitment by foreign tribe leaders should be limited if farming a tribe is an acknowledged tactic. There are also edge cases to consider, like if elementals, buzzards, or other summoned things should give mana.



    There is room for a lot of new technologies to be added. Perhaps you won’t ever get all the technologies, even by the end of the game. So you might have to make some tough choices about what to research.

    • This reply was modified 2 weeks, 6 days ago by  Keeperman.


    I did like if you expand the “floor” mechanics, and let we place biomes with it: Arctic, Desert, Jungle, Water/lake, Lava, etc…
    Some minions that live in that biomes: Yuki-onna(“snow woman” Japanese folklore), Yetis; Sandpit Bug, Sand-Worms (like Dune); Arachnid in jungle with Web between trees; water Mermaids, lava Red Dragon, etc…

    Also did like if there was more variation of equipment, like Leather Armor, Chitin Armor, Dragon Scale Armor, Bone Spear, Fang Daggers, Spider Silk Bow, “Magic Wood Staff”, etc… so corpse would not just be used to make undead.
    That would incentive player to to the world-map to hunt.

    • This reply was modified 1 week, 6 days ago by  Fortaleza. Reason: more itens ideas
    • This reply was modified 1 week, 6 days ago by  Fortaleza.
    • This reply was modified 1 week, 6 days ago by  Fortaleza.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.


Jul, 25

Upcoming gameplay changes, part II: combat

The previous blog post about progression has stirred a lot of discussion, and I want to follow up a little bit, before I go into the main topic of this post. If you haven't read... more

Jul, 03

Upcoming gameplay changes, part I

I recently stumbled upon an old Reddit "AMA" by Tynan Sylvester, the author of Rimworld. I hope he doesn't mind if I quote chunk of one of his answers here. "What designers need... more

Jun, 14

KeeperRL Alpha22 is released!

KeeperRL Alpha22 is out! The update features a dedicated tutorial, as well as many technical and gameplay improvements. Check out the changelog below for details. As always,... more

May, 26

Release plan for Alpha22

It's slowly the time to wrap up the release of the twenty-second Alpha. The plans for this version were ambitious, but I had to postpone many of them, otherwise the update would... more

Apr, 14

Improvements under the hood

Many changes have happened in KeeperRL land in the last few weeks. Most of them were in the game's internals, so they may not be very interesting to you, but they are important... more



There are no other games out there like KeeperRL. The game is a unique mixture of management, levelling, crafting, constructing, exploring, adventure etc. […] The possibility of interacting with other’s players monumental dungeons turn KeeperRL into one of the most promising games I’ve found.


This game is amazing! It’s challenging, fun, unique, and exactly what you might expect it to be. For an early access game it’s incredible. And the thought that there’s more to come thrills me! I can’t wait to see how this awesome game will develop even more.


Any time I touch another race, I get bent over like a cheap, overworked sex worker. I love sucking at this game so much.