First off, I’m not sure if this bug is specific to my operating system.
THE BUG: When I start up the game and the “fancy cursor” does not appear I have to double-click or triple-click every in places I would have to single click normally. On top of this, it makes the menus very glitchy and just clicking anywhere has about a 50% chance of not working at all.
I was able to fix this after restarting the game after playing for an hour. But I had no idea when I started the game the first time that I was encountering a bug and I just thought the controls were awful.
So if you ever encounter the glitch where the fancy cursor doesn’t appear when you start the game (when it’s enabled in the options) just restart the game. Otherwise the game is near unplayable.