A little bit too shiny maybe, but why not ! I think we need to see it ingame, with a real mock up or a quick test, to see if it fits.
Actually i think the current UI is not so bad and fits with the general feeling of the game. Instead of spending time on the IU, maybe simply focus on gameplay and content ?
I will pick the elements (there are many) such that it's not too shiny. But I really need something better looking if only to please my eye when I'm developing 🙂
